Authors
On November 19, the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) released its Draft Capital Adequacy Requirements Guideline (2028), which proposes targeted revisions to the guideline as part of OSFI’s new Competitive Prudential Initiative1. The Competitive Prudential Initiative is a made-in-Canada approach that is meant to maintain the resilience of Canada's financial system while increasing capacity to take reasonable risks, compete, and innovate with confidence—and it aligns with measures outlined in Budget 2026 (which proposed the introduction of a secondary competition mandate for OSFI). These draft capital rules are open for public consultation until February 17, 2027.
As noted in our bulletin about whether OSFI should rethink AT1 capital requirements for federal credit unions, and our bulletin on Budget 2025’s proposals for small and mid-sized federal financial institutions, we have been advocating for OSFI to (i) eliminate the requirement for Alternative Tier 1 (AT1) capital for SMSBs and replace it with Tier 2 capital, and (ii) no longer require SMSBs to include non-viability contingent capital (NVCC) terms in their AT1 and Tier 2 capital instruments.
The proposed targeted revisions to the Capital Adequacy Requirements Guideline (which would take effect on November 1, 2027 or January 1, 2028 for institutions with a fiscal year ending October 31 or December 31, respectively) have adopted our recommendations. They remove the minimum and supervisory target Tier 1 risk-based capital requirements for SMSBs (who will continue to be subject to Common Equity Tier 1 and Total Capital requirements) and the NVCC requirements for SMSBs2.
With respect to credit unions specifically, we believe these amendments will significantly reduce barriers faced by provincial credit unions with large investment share capital bases that would not have otherwise qualified as AT1 capital under the federal regime due to the NVCC requirement. Furthermore, replacing AT1 with Tier 2 capital requirements should enable federal credit unions to raise qualifying regulatory capital more efficiently and cost-effectively than they currently are able. However, we were surprised that there was no specific reference to changing the approach to setting the leverage ratio for SMSBs.
Prior to the financial crisis, Canada, unlike many jurisdictions, had a leverage constraint that was based on total capital, but after the financial crisis, OSFI has imposed a leverage ratio based on Tier 1 capital consistent with Basel III requirements. We understand anecdotally that OSFI has imposed a much more conservative leverage ratio than the 3% Basel III minimum, particularly for smaller institutions, which in some cases may have become a binding constraint. In order for the replacement of AT1 with Tier 2 capital to be a meaningful change, we had anticipated that OSFI would have also changed its approach to the leverage ratio requirements. For example, we were expecting that the leverage ratio that OSFI imposed on a particular institution based on Tier 1 capital would be moved closer to 3% while adding a supplementary leverage ratio based on Total Capital that is more constraining (and closer to the existing leverage ratio that the institution may be subject to). This could be accomplished by imposing, say, a 4% or 5% Tier 1 capital leverage ratio and imposing a 6% to 7% total capital leverage ratio3. We expect this will be addressed as a consequential amendment when OSFI releases an updated Leverage Requirements Guideline.
Related to the capital ratios above, OSFI is proposing to introduce for SMSBs a preferential treatment for general residential real estate secured lending exposures with credit bureau scores above 720 and lower-risk mortgages with loan-to-value (LTV) ratios. For example, for residential mortgages with a LTV of less than 60%, the capital requirements would be decreased by 50% from the current standardized approach (SA) capital requirement, which may significantly decrease an SMSB’s required capital and bump its capital ratios accordingly4. These changes should free up capital to make additional loans with the same capital base and at lower interest rates, since less capital will be needed to support those loans. This should both increase access to funding for residential mortgages and corporate loans at lower rates and make them more affordable, which is consistent with the direction set out in Budget 20265.
OSFI is also proposing to introduce lower-risk weights for SMSBs related to corporate exposures6 as follows:
|
Category |
CAR 2027 SA |
Draft CAR 2028 SA |
|
Corporate small and medium sized enterprises |
75% |
65% |
|
Corporate (flat RW) |
100% |
80% |
|
Unrated corporate – investment grade |
65% |
60% |
In addition to the above, OSFI is proposing to7:
|
LTV |
CAR 2027 SA |
Draft CAR 2028 SA |
|
<50% |
20.0% |
10.0% |
|
50%<LTV=< 60% |
25.0% |
12.5% |
|
60%<LTV=< 70% |
30.0% |
20.0% |
|
70%<LTV=< 80% |
35.0% |
27.5% |
|
80%<LTV=< 90% |
40.0% |
35.0% |
|
90%<LTV=< 100% |
50.0% |
45.0% |
|
LTV > 100% |
70.0% |
65.0% |
To discuss these issues, please contact the author(s).
This publication is a general discussion of certain legal and related developments and should not be relied upon as legal advice. If you require legal advice, we would be pleased to discuss the issues in this publication with you, in the context of your particular circumstances.
For permission to republish this or any other publication, contact Bryn Turnbull.
© 2026 by Torys LLP. All rights reserved.