Starfish Specialty Insurance receives strategic investment from Peloton Capital
Torys acted as counsel to Peloton Capital Management with a team that included Stefan Stauder, Heding Yang, Alastair Smith and Isabella Picui (corporate/M&A) and Ellie Kang (employment).
On December 17, 2025, Starfish Specialty Insurance announced that it entered into a partnership with Peloton Capital Management to support its growth trajectory and position the company to make strategic acquisitions. The investment will give Peloton a significant minority stake in the company alongside the founders.
Further information can be found on Peloton’s website.
Starfish Specialty Insurance is a fast-growing independent MGA underwriting admitted and surplus lines programs. They are supported by a panel of high-quality insurers and reinsurers. It currently offers more than ten products across five verticals: Community Associations, Real Estate Investors, Aviation, Staffing/PEO’s and Crisis Response.
Peloton Capital Management is a private investment firm that utilizes a long-term investment philosophy and sector-focused strategy to partner with founders and management teams to help build exceptional businesses and create attractive returns for investors. Headquartered in Toronto, Canada, Peloton Capital was founded and is led by a team with extensive private equity experience.